Find Out if the Vankey Umbrella Cast Iron Cap Enhances Your Kamado Joe Grill

Description

Grilling Performance

Using this umbrella-shaped cast iron cap as a replacement for the original Kamado Joe top vent was a bit of a game-changer for me. I noticed an immediate improvement in grilling performance, especially during those unexpected summer showers. Unlike the old daisy wheel design, this one kept rain from seeping into the grill, which was a lifesaver for maintaining consistent heat. It’s also great for controlling airflow. I tested it during a long, slow smoke for ribs, and it held the temperature steady for hours. However, it’s worth mentioning that achieving high temperatures above 500°F was a bit of a struggle; the airflow seems slightly restricted at maximum vent settings.

Temperature Control

The five-speed smoke exhaust adjustment on this cap is pure genius. It provides precise temperature control, which is critical for getting those perfect sear marks on steaks or a low-and-slow cook for brisket. I love the numbered settings—it’s so much easier than the guesswork I used to do. During my first test, I played around with the settings to find the sweet spot for baking pizza. It worked, but there’s a learning curve; if you’re used to the original Kamado vent, this one might take some getting used to. A small gripe: the markings could be a bit more visible in low light, especially for evening grilling sessions.

Cleaning

Cleaning this replacement part isn’t as intimidating as I initially thought. The split-type design makes it easy to disassemble and thoroughly clean, which is a massive improvement over the original model. After a few weeks of regular use, I noticed grease buildup, but nothing a quick wipe-down couldn’t handle. I’ve seen some reviews mentioning that the interior paint might peel off after exposure to high heat, but I didn’t experience that during my tests. Still, it’s something to keep in mind if you frequently cook at very high temperatures.

Durability

The Vankey umbrella-shaped cast aluminum cap feels sturdy but surprisingly lightweight. I accidentally dropped it while trying to fit it onto the grill, and it survived without a scratch—though I wouldn’t recommend testing its limits too often. It’s worth noting that the cast aluminum won’t rust like some other materials, which is a huge plus if you live in a humid climate like mine. However, I did worry about how well it would hold up over time, especially the moving parts. Only time will tell, but so far, it’s holding strong.

Features

One of the standout features of this cap is its ability to adapt to various grilling scenarios. You can remove the cover to increase airflow for rapid ignition or keep it on to control smoke levels. This versatility made it a joy to use during a family barbecue last weekend. The umbrella shape isn’t just for show—it’s genuinely practical for grilling in unpredictable weather. I do wish it came in a few more color options; the red is nice but doesn’t quite match my black Kamado Joe grill.

Portability & Storage

While this isn’t the kind of grill accessory you’ll be lugging around, its compact size does make it easy to store when not in use. I simply toss it in the drawer with my other grilling tools. The lightweight design also makes it a breeze to install and remove. That said, if you’re someone who likes to take your grill accessories on camping trips or tailgates, this piece won’t weigh you down.

Warranty

I was a bit disappointed to find that the warranty details weren’t as clear as I’d hoped. It seems like there’s no extended coverage beyond the standard return window. For a product that’s designed to endure high heat and outdoor conditions, a more robust warranty would have been reassuring.

Challenges

• Removing the cap for rapid airflow can be tricky if it’s greasy or hot.
• Achieving ultra-high grilling temperatures might not be as effortless as with other vent designs.
• Paint peeling on the interior was reported by some users, though I haven’t seen it yet.
• The two-piece design, while convenient for cleaning, isn’t physically connected, making it easy to misplace one part.

Strong Points

• Excellent rain and snow protection, keeping the grill safe and dry.
• Lightweight yet durable cast aluminum construction, resistant to rust.
• Five-speed adjustment for precise temperature control.
• Easy to clean and maintain thanks to the split design.

Competitive Options

When comparing this cap to other replacement chimney tops, the original Kamado Joe Kontrol Tower comes to mind. While the Kontrol Tower is a fan favorite for its sleek design and reliability, it’s notoriously difficult to find in stock. This umbrella-shaped cap offers a solid alternative, especially considering the added rain protection. However, it lacks the polished finish and seamless fit of the Kontrol Tower. Other brands offer simpler daisy wheel replacements, but they miss out on the advanced features like the five-speed adjustment.

Affordable Quality

For its price point, this replacement cap offers solid value. It’s not the cheapest option out there, but the added features and durable materials make it feel like a worthwhile investment. Compared to similar products, it strikes a good balance between functionality and cost, especially if you’re looking for something that performs well in all weather conditions. While it’s not perfect, it’s certainly a step up from the standard options available.

Additional information