How to Choose a Grill: What Actually Matters
Recommended picks
Fuel Type: Gas, Charcoal, or Pellet
Propane is the most popular choice for backyard grilling because tanks are easy to swap and you get consistent heat from the first minute. Natural gas costs less per cook and never runs dry mid-session, but it requires a permanent gas line, which not every yard has. Charcoal runs hotter and adds smoke flavor that gas simply cannot replicate, but you spend 20 to 30 minutes getting coals ready and cleanup takes longer. Pellet grills automate temperature control and produce real wood smoke, but they need an electrical outlet and cost more upfront. Think about your setup before you buy: if you grill on a condo balcony or tailgate regularly, a compact propane model makes more sense than a heavy pellet grill.
Cooking Area: How Much Grill Do You Need
Cooking area is measured in square inches and is the most practical spec to use when sizing a grill. A solo griller or a couple can get by with 150 to 250 square inches, which is enough for four to six burgers at once. Families of four to six people generally want 350 to 600 square inches so everything comes off the grill at the same time instead of in batches. The Cuisinart CGG-306 is a good example at the smaller end, offering 275 square inches across 2 burners for around $146 and carrying a 4.4-star rating from nearly 7,000 reviewers. If you cook for crowds regularly, look at options with 600 square inches or more, like the Royal Gourmet GD401C, which gives you 610 square inches across 4 burners at $259.99. Note that some listings inflate totals by including a warming rack, so compare primary cooking grates when comparing models.
BTUs and Burners: What the Numbers Mean
BTUs measure how much heat a burner can produce per hour, but more BTUs do not automatically mean better grilling. What matters is BTU output relative to the cooking area. A rough target is 80 to 100 BTUs per square inch of primary cooking surface. A grill producing 10,000 BTUs over 275 square inches falls right in that range and will sear well. The number of burners matters more for flexibility: 2 burners let you set up a basic two-zone fire with one side hot and one side lower, which is essential for thicker cuts that need a sear followed by gentler finishing heat. Three or four burners give you more zones and more control over simultaneous cooking at different temperatures. The Charbroil 463773717 offers 3 burners and 360 square inches at $199, rated 4.5 stars across 3,500 reviews, and is a practical mid-range choice for families who want that zone control without a large footprint.
Materials and Build Quality
Stainless steel cooking grates resist rust and are easier to clean than raw steel, but porcelain-coated cast iron grates hold heat more evenly and produce better sear marks. The lid and firebox material matters for how long the grill lasts outdoors. Thicker stainless steel on the lid and body handles weather better than thin sheet metal that dents and rusts in a season or two. Check the lid fit: a tight seal keeps heat in and makes indirect cooking and smoking more effective. If the grill will live outdoors year round, pair it with a fitted cover regardless of the material. Heavier grills are generally built to a higher standard, so weight can be a rough proxy for construction quality when comparing otherwise similar models.
Freestanding vs. Built-In vs. Tabletop
Most buyers want a freestanding grill on a cart, which rolls out of a shed or sits on a patio and does not require any permanent installation. Built-in grills drop into an outdoor kitchen island and are a fixed investment tied to a specific location. Tabletop and countertop models are compact and portable, which makes them practical for camping, tailgating, balconies, or as a second grill for quick weeknight cooks. Weight is an honest signal of portability: a freestanding grill at 87 pounds is not going to a campsite, but an 18-pound tabletop model travels easily. Match the install type to how you actually plan to use the grill.
Budget and What to Expect at Each Price Range
Under $150 you get a compact 1 to 2 burner grill that works for small households and occasional use, usually with thinner metal construction. From $150 to $300 you find the sweet spot for most backyard grillers: 2 to 4 burners, 275 to 600 square inches, and better materials that hold up to regular use. From $300 to $600 you get larger cooking surfaces, more burners for zone cooking, and heavier construction. Above $600, you are generally paying for premium stainless steel, higher BTU output, additional side burners, or specialty designs like infrared or built-in configurations. Buy as much grill as you will realistically use, not the biggest one on the floor.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Choosing a grill by BTU rating alone without checking the cooking area it serves, which can result in a grill that runs too hot or wastes fuel.
- Buying too small for the number of people you actually cook for, which forces you to cook in batches and eat in shifts.
- Ignoring lid fit and body thickness in favor of features, leading to a grill that loses heat and rusts within two seasons.
- Not accounting for the fuel source available at the grill location before buying, then realizing a natural gas model needs a permanent line or a pellet grill needs an outlet.
- Confusing total cooking area with primary cooking grate area by counting a flimsy warming rack as part of the usable surface.
- Skipping a grill cover for an outdoor grill, which shortens the lifespan of even a well-built model significantly.
Frequently asked questions
How many BTUs do I need for a backyard grill?
A general rule is 80 to 100 BTUs per square inch of primary cooking surface. A 275 square inch grill with 10,000 BTUs is well-matched for everyday grilling. Going much higher than that ratio does not improve results and can make heat management harder.
What cooking area is right for a family of four?
Plan on roughly 75 to 100 square inches per person if you want to cook everything in one round. For four people, 350 to 450 square inches works well for burgers, chicken pieces, and similar portions. If you host larger groups, 600 square inches gives you room to grill sides at the same time.
Is a gas grill or charcoal grill better?
Gas grills are faster and more convenient: you are grilling in under 10 minutes with consistent, adjustable heat. Charcoal burns hotter, adds a distinct smoky flavor, and costs less to buy upfront, but startup and cleanup take more time. The better choice depends on how much you value convenience versus flavor and how often you grill.
Can I convert a propane grill to natural gas?
Many freestanding propane grills can be converted to natural gas with a conversion kit, but only if the manufacturer explicitly supports it for that model. The orifices that regulate gas flow are different between the two fuel types, so you cannot simply connect a natural gas line without the right hardware. Check the manufacturer documentation before attempting any conversion.
How do I cook meat to a safe temperature on a grill?
The most reliable method is a leave-in or instant-read thermometer placed in the thickest part of the meat, away from bone. Follow USDA safe cooking temperatures for each meat type. A thermometer removes all guesswork and works on any grill regardless of brand or fuel type.