Monument Grills 98457 Smoker Review
Our verdict
The Monument Grills 98457 is a stainless steel propane-compatible smoker box at $23.98, priced at the upper end of the budget smoker box tier. With 207 reviews at 4.5 stars it has solid early performance data and is a natural fit for anyone already cooking on a Monument gas grill.
Check price on AmazonBest for
Monument Grills gas grill owners who want a brand-matched smoker box, and general gas grill users looking for a stainless steel option under $25
Skip if
You want cast iron heat retention, or need a box with published dimensions to verify grill fitment before buying
- Fuel Propane
- Material Stainless Steel
- Color Silver
- Weight 1.63 lb
- Priced 93% below the category median ($329.50 across 122 tracked models)
- Weight of 1.63 lb - lighter than 88% of the 122 models we track
Pros
- Stainless steel construction resists rust without special maintenance
- At 1.63 pounds, slightly heavier than ultra-lightweight boxes for better heat retention
- 4.5-star rating across 207 reviews is solid
- Brand-matched for Monument Grills owners
- Propane-optimized design for gas grills
Cons
- 207 reviews is a smaller sample than competing boxes with 600 to 1,700 reviews
- No dimensions published, making it hard to verify fitment on non-Monument grills
- Priced at $23.98, a small premium over similarly-rated alternatives with more reviews
Our scorecard
-
Owner rating4.5/5
4.5 average across 207 owner ratings
-
Popularity3.0/5
207 owner reviews, more than most models here
The overall score is owner satisfaction weighted by how many reviews back it, so a high rating from few reviews counts for less. The bars below show where this model stands against the other grills, grill parts and burners, smokers and smoking gear, grill tools, outdoor griddles, outdoor kitchen appliances and grill covers we track in this category on price, popularity and size. Context, not marks against it, and our read of the data, not a lab test.
Overview
['The Monument Grills 98457 is built from stainless steel in a silver finish, runs on propane as its fuel type, and weighs 1.63 pounds. At that weight it is heavier than the lightest budget boxes, suggesting a somewhat thicker gauge of steel that should hold heat more consistently.', 'Monument Grills produces a line of gas grills sold widely at home improvement retailers, and this smoker box is part of their accessories line. For owners of Monument gas grills, it is designed to fit those grates, though it will work on any standard gas grill as well.', 'At $23.98 with 207 reviews this is a newer-to-market or slower-moving accessory compared to competitors with 700 or more reviews. The 4.5-star average across those 207 reviews is promising but represents a smaller sample than higher-count competitors.']
Specifications
| Fuel | Propane |
|---|---|
| Material | Stainless Steel |
| Color | Silver |
| Weight | 1.63 lb |
Performance notes
Fuel type is propane, meaning the box is intended for gas grill use. Stainless steel material with a 1.63-pound weight puts it above the lightest thin-sheet boxes in terms of heat retention. No BTU, cooking area, burner count or dimension specifications are available. Performance relative to similar stainless steel boxes at this price should be comparable based on material and weight.
What buyers say
207 reviews at 4.5 stars is a positive early signal. The lower total review count means there is less data to detect edge-case quality issues. Buyers so far are satisfied, and the Monument Grills brand association suggests consistent manufacturing standards across their product line.
Similar grills, grill parts and burners, smokers and smoking gear, grill tools, outdoor griddles, outdoor kitchen appliances and grill covers to consider
Frequently asked questions
Will this smoker box fit on grills other than Monument brand?
Smoker boxes generally fit on any grill where they can rest on the grate above a burner. Since Monument has not published exact dimensions for this box, measure the clearance on your specific grill and contact Monument Grills directly at [email protected] if you need exact fitment specs before purchasing.
Is 207 reviews enough to trust this product?
207 reviews at 4.5 stars is a reasonable amount of feedback for a brand-accessory product, though it is smaller than the 700 to 1,700 review counts on some competing boxes. If you already own a Monument Grills gas grill and want a matched accessory, the rating makes it worth considering. If you are brand-agnostic, you may find more buyer data from competing stainless steel options at a similar price.
What wood chips should I use with a propane grill smoker box?
On a propane grill, the chip variety matters less to the box than it does to the flavor profile you want. Hickory and oak are strong, classic choices for beef and pork. Apple and pecan give a lighter smoke that works well with chicken and vegetables. Soak chips for 20 to 30 minutes before use to slow combustion and stretch smoke time.